Jurisdiction of the New York State Supreme Court Commercial Division
The New York Commercial Division is part of the New York State Supreme Court and was created to handle complicated commercial cases in their respective jurisdictions. There are specific rules that apply for a case to be handled by the Commercial Division. These rules are as follows.
Each of the ten jurisdictions of the Commercial Division has its requirements on the amount of monetary claim that must be sought for them to handle the case. These amounts are exclusive of punitive damages, interests, costs, disbursements, and counsel fees.
The jurisdictional thresholds to qualify for the Commercial Division vary by county. Here are the limits as of 2021 within the following counties. These limits may change frequently depending on caseload.
- Nassau $200,000
- Suffolk $100,000
- Westchester $100,000
- Onondaga $50,000
- Queens $100,000
- Kings (Brooklyn) $150,000
- New York (Manhattan) $500,000
The Commercial Division will hear cases that involve the following causes of action, provided that the monetary threshold listed above is met or if equitable or declaratory relief is sought:
- Breach of contract or fiduciary duty fraud, misrepresentation, business tort, statutory or common law actions where the breach alleged arises out of business dealings
- Transactions included in the Uniform Commercial Code, except those involving cooperatives or condominium units
- Transactions involving commercial real property, such as Yellowstone injunctions, but excluding actions that only involve rent payments
- Business transactions involving or arising out of dealings with financial institutions, including commercial banks
- Internal affairs of business organizations
- Malpractice complaints against accountants, actuaries, and legal malpractice arising out of representation in commercial matters
- Environmental insurance coverage
- Commercial insurance coverage
Under the rules of the commercial division, the following causes of action do not have to meet the monetary threshold listed above:
- Shareholder derivatives action
- Commercial class actions
- Dissolution of corporations, partnerships, LLCs, LLPs, and joint ventures
Generally, the Commercial Division would not handle non-commercial causes of actions even if they meet the monetary threshold. These non-commercial causes of action may include:
- Lawsuits to collect professional fees
- Cases seeking a declaratory judgment as to insurance coverage for personal injury or property damage
- Residential real estate disputes, including landlord-tenant, commercial real estate disputes on rent payment only
- Home improvement contracts for residential property for up to four residential units or individual units in a residential building, including cooperatives and condominiums
- Proceedings to enforce a judgment regardless of the nature of the underlying case
- First-party insurance claims and actions by insurance to collect premiums or rescind non-commercial policies
- An attorney malpractice action unless they arose out of representation in a commercial matter
Assignment to the Commercial Division
Suppose a party wishes to get the case assigned to the Commercial Division. In that case, that party must do so by filing a Request for Judicial Intervention (RJI) and a completed Commercial Division RJI Addendum that certifies that the case meets the monetary threshold and one of the causes of action set by the jurisdiction. Failure to file an RJI precludes a party from seeking assignment of the case to the Commercial Division.
The parties to the complaint may also consent to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commercial Division of the Supreme Court. Parties can do this by stating so in their choice of law or provision sections of the contract. As noted above, this is only permissible if the case has met both the monetary threshold and cause of action requirements.
The request for assignment to the Commercial Division must be made within 90 days of the services of the complaint.
Transfer into the Commercial Division
If an RJI was filed within the 90-day window, but the filing party did not designate the case as “commercial,” then any other party may then request to transfer the case into the commercial division by filing a letter application to the Administrative Judge within ten days after the receipt of a copy of the RJI.
Moreover, the non-commercial division justice handling the case may request the Administrative judge to transfer the case to the commercial division, provided that it meets the money threshold and cause of action requirement.
Note that the Administrative Judge’s decision regarding this transfer is considered final and not subject to further administrative appeal.
Transfer From the Commercial Division
As noted above, the Commercial Division justice handling the case may transfer a case to a non-commercial part of the court if they deem it not to meet the monetary threshold and cause of action requirement.
Moreover, a party that is aggrieved by a transfer of a case to a non-commercial part of the court may ask the Administrative judge to review the transfer by filing a letter application within ten days of the receipt of the case’s designation to a non-commercial part.
Similar to the situation listed above, the ruling of the Administrative judge regarding the transfer of the case is final and not subject to further administrative appeal.